Don Pedro Horruytiner House – haunted house

    Don Pedro Horruytiner House

    House·Status Unknown·Unknown·Updated April 23, 2026
    Do you believe this location is haunted?
    1Experiences
    3Sources
    2Hotspots
    0Reviews
    1Entities

    Background & History

    Historical context and known paranormal claims surrounding Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    The Don Pedro Horruytiner House stands as a historic property steeped in the rich cultural heritage of Spanish colonial America, its architecture and interior design reflecting centuries of occupation and significant historical transition. Originally constructed during the colonial period in what would become the southeastern United States, the residence represents the substantial domestic architecture typical of prominent families of the era, with its distinctive design elements and careful construction methods that have allowed it to survive into the modern age despite centuries of environmental exposure and changing ownership. The house served as residence to successive generations of its namesake family, the Horruytiner lineage, whose prominence in regional affairs ensured the property remained a point of documented historical interest throughout its long existence. Throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the house remained in private hands, with various residents occupying its rooms and conducting their daily lives within its walls. The property witnessed numerous significant life events—births, deaths, marriages, and the everyday routines of families whose names have faded from local memory but whose presence left permanent imprints upon the structure itself. By the early nineteenth century, the house had accumulated considerable history within its physical spaces.

    The paranormal phenomena documented at the Don Pedro Horruytiner House centers on apparitions with direct connection to the property's documented past, suggesting a connection between the spirits and the visual records preserved within the residence. In 1821, visitor Brigita Gomez reported a remarkable encounter within the house in which two distinctly translucent female figures appeared before her, their ethereal forms visible and recognizable to the observer. These apparitions did not manifest as merely sensory impressions or undefined shadow figures, but rather presented themselves with sufficient clarity to allow for detailed observation and comparison with other evidence of their identities. The two translucent women appeared to match the physical descriptions found in a painting kept within the house, depicting two women who had previously resided there during an earlier period. This direct correlation between the visual appearance of the spirits and the portrait found in the residence provides a substantial basis for the identification of the entities involved. Beyond the visual manifestation, the encounter included a physical element that defied conventional explanation—the apparitions reportedly left behind a gift of yellow roses, flowers that subsequently became a notable detail in the historical record of the haunting. These yellow roses, appearing seemingly from nowhere and left by spirits, represent one of the most tangible pieces of evidence associated with the encounter. The flowers left by the ghostly visitors have become emblematic of the haunting itself and remain central to narratives about the location.

    The identities of the two translucent women are believed to be connected to the painting discovered within the house, suggesting they may have been former occupants of the residence, possibly the wives or daughters of earlier proprietors or family members of significant standing. Their decision to manifest specifically in the form that matched their likenesses in the painting suggests a connection to the visual legacy they left behind, as if the portrait itself served as a focal point for their continued presence in the location. The fact that the manifestations occurred in 1821, already centuries after the house's construction, indicates that the spirits may have lingered for extended periods before revealing themselves to a living observer, or that their manifestation at that particular moment carried specific significance. The yellow roses left behind possess symbolic weight that has never been fully explained—whether they represent a gesture of peace, a spiritual gift, or some form of communication from the other side remains subject to interpretation and speculation. The choice of yellow roses as opposed to other varieties might itself carry meaning, as colors and flower types have long held symbolic significance in various cultural traditions.

    In contemporary times, the Don Pedro Horruytiner House continues to function as a point of historical and paranormal interest within its community, with the documented encounter of 1821 remaining among the most well-researched historical hauntings on record due to the specificity of the witness account and the presence of corroborating evidence in the form of the painting. The house maintains its physical structure and architectural integrity, though modifications and repairs have been necessary to preserve it through changing environmental conditions and the passage of additional centuries. Visitors and researchers interested in documented paranormal phenomena continue to reference the Horruytiner House as a case study in hauntings with identifiable entities, where the apparitions possessed characteristics sufficiently distinct to allow for their recognition and verification against historical records maintained within the residence itself. The combination of visual documentation in portrait form, the eyewitness account from a credible observer, and the unexplained physical evidence of the flower gift create a historically significant record of paranormal activity that distinguishes this location from less-documented haunting reports.

    Type

    house

    Location

    St. Augustine, Florida

    County

    St. Johns County

    Coordinates

    29.891653, -81.31293

    Added to Archive

    February 26, 2026

    Current Status

    Status Unknown

    People Also Searched For

    You Might Also Like

    1.Ms. Caroline’s Guest House
    Ms. Caroline’s Guest House
    (0 reviews)

    Saint Augustine, the oldest continuously occupied European settlement within the present-day United States, occupies a unique position in American colonial history, having been founded in 1565 by Spanish explorer Pedro Menéndez de Avilés and continuously inhabited for nearly five centuries through S… read more

    St. Augustine, Florida · house

    2.St. Augustine Lighthouse
    St. Augustine Lighthouse
    (0 reviews)

    The St. Augustine Lighthouse stands as a prominent coastal sentinel in Florida's oldest city, its 165-foot tower rising majestically from the northeastern shores completed between 1871 and 1875. The structure represented a significant engineering achievement of the Victorian period, constructed with… read more

    St. Augustine, Florida · lighthouse

    3.King-Cromartie House
    King-Cromartie House
    (0 reviews)

    The King-Cromartie House in Fort Lauderdale, Florida stands as a historic structure built in 1907 by contractor Edwin T. King, representing early twentieth-century residential architecture and embodying the growing prosperity of the Florida region during the post-Reconstruction era. The house's cons… read more

    Fort Lauderdale, Florida · house

    Have you visited Don Pedro Horruytiner House?

    Share your paranormal experience and help other investigators decide if it's worth exploring.

    Activity Breakdown
    1

    Types of documented activity recorded at Don Pedro Horruytiner House, organized by category.

    Visual Activity

    1
    Apparitions

    Reported Areas
    2

    Specific areas within Don Pedro Horruytiner House where activity has been documented.

    Yard

    0 mentions across reports & reviews

    0

    throughout house

    0 mentions across reports & reviews

    0

    Known Entities
    1

    Entities, spirits, and figures that have been identified or reported at Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    Two translucent women ghosts from painting

    Photos
    1

    Images sourced from across the web and linked directly to the original host. Ghouler does not download or host these images, nor do we claim them as our own.

    Don Pedro Horruytiner House - Photo 1

    Investigator Reviews
    0

    Your trust is our priority, so no location can pay to alter or remove their reviews.

    No reviews yet.

    Be the first to share your experience at Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    Find reviews useful? Help others by sharing your experience.

    Ms. Caroline’s Guest House

    Ms. Caroline’s Guest House

    St. Augustine, Florida

    Be the first to review!
    St. Augustine Lighthouse

    St. Augustine Lighthouse

    St. Augustine, Florida

    Be the first to review!
    King-Cromartie House

    King-Cromartie House

    Fort Lauderdale, Florida

    Be the first to review!
    Barkley House

    Barkley House

    Pensacola, Florida

    Be the first to review!

    Contact Information

    214 St. George St, St. Augustine, Florida

    29.891653, -81.31293

    Access

    Unknown

    Status

    Status Unknown

    Documented Experiences
    0

    Paranormal reports and documented occurrences compiled for Don Pedro Horruytiner House from archived sources and community investigators.

    No documented experiences for Don Pedro Horruytiner House yet.

    Have you visited Don Pedro Horruytiner House? Logging your experience helps build the case file and gives future investigators a clearer picture of what to expect.

    Best Times to Visit

    Equipment & Methods

    Equipment and investigation methods reported by community investigators at Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    Know Before You Go
    0

    Important details to help plan your visit or investigation of Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    Access Level

    Unknown

    Status

    Status Unknown

    Environment

    Not specified

    Sources & References
    3

    Referenced materials and documentation supporting the Don Pedro Horruytiner House case file.

    Experience Glossary
    1

    Detailed descriptions of each type of activity documented at Don Pedro Horruytiner House.

    Apparitions

    visual phenomenon

    Definition

    A reported visual sighting of a human-like or shadow-like figure without a physical source.

    What People Report

    Witnesses describe full-body figures, partial forms, or fleeting silhouettes appearing in hallways, doorways, or peripheral vision. These sightings are typically brief and may vanish when directly observed.

    Browse all locations with apparitions

    Important Notices

    Information in this case file is compiled from public sources and community reports. Accuracy cannot be guaranteed. Always verify details before visiting, and check with property owners and local or state authorities to confirm access is permitted.